Guest Stars Josh Zuckerman as Max Miller Wes Brown as Taylor Williams Peyton List as Lindsey Beckwith Rob Mayes as Colin Andrews Nicole Paggi as Carrie Anne Monroe Ashley Roberts as Penny Ryan Lochte as Himself Co Starring Whitney Hoy as Katie Maloney Mia Serafino as Ryan Lochte's Girlfriend Donnell Turner as Waiter Alexander George as Busboy