Guest Stars C.J. Hoff as Aaron McCready Pete Burris as Ogden Gabriel Michael Bateman as Joshua Austin Abraham Benrubi as Caleb Willie C. Carpenter as Norville Grant Co Starring Callie McClincy as Holly Holter Chandler Head as Amber Barnes Jill Jane Clements as Florence Lacy Camp as Betsy Austin Zach Shirey as Young Kyle Dakota Lee as Mindy Austin April Turner as Nurse Jackie Prucha as Regina