Guest Stars David Castro as Raphael Santiago Alan van Sprang as Valentine Morgenstern Maxim Roy as Jocelyn Fray Jon Cor as Hodge Starkweather Stephanie Bennett as Lydia Branwell Mimi Kuzyk as Imogen Herondale Raymond Ablack as Raj Shailene Garnett as Maureen Brown Adam Harrington as Michael Wayland Co Starring Joel Labelle as Alaric Rodriguez Jordan Hudyma as Blackwell Stephen R. Hart as Brother Jeremiah