Guest Stars Ben Feldman as Fred Gregory Alan Williams as Judge Warren Libby Brandy Norwood as Elisa Shayne Tom Nowicki as Geoff Hensley Cynthia Barrett as Judge Freeland David Kronawitter as A.U.S.A. Blaine Jaden D. Harmon as Eric Shayne Brian Patrick Clarke as Curtis hunter Robert Hoffman as Brian Pullman Katherine McNamara as Ann Logan Edward Herrmann as Reverend Phillips Gil McKinney as Ben Logan Elliott Grey as Mark Stout Courtney Patterson as Julie Co Starring John Pontrelli as Director Eric Esquer as Attorney Amanda Lavassani as Attractive Female