Guest Stars Aidan Quinn as Matt Furey Terry Kinney as Deputy Attorney General Zach Williams James McCaffrey as Frank Angstrom David Call as Martin Charlie Hofheimer as Ethan Foster Jenna Stern as AAG Kate Cooley Keith David as Miles Grant Will Chase as Artie Flom Co Starring Edelen McWilliams as Patti Murphy / Juror Number Seven Larry Pine as Wallace Warren Kenneth Tigar as Professor Marnie Schulenburg as Annabeth Mills William Oliver Watkins as Steve Adam Mastrelli as Officer Jeff Benson Reese Madigan as AAG Max Klein James Michael Farrell as Detective #3 Nick Gregory as John Andrea Weston as Judge Myrna Malkin Rebecca Brooksher as Carly O'Keefe Mike Houston as Officer Joseph Callahan Frank Liotti as Detective #1 Lisa Barnes as Mrs. Feldman Peggy Gormley as Judge Arlene Cooper Lee Roy Rogers as Sandra Warren Amanda Ramirez as Jury Foreman Giuseppe Maione as Henry Rusty Sneary as AAG Greg Oliver