Guest Stars Joe Morton as Eli Pope George Newbern as Charlie Kate Burton as Sally Langston Brian Letscher as Tom Larsen Dan Bucatinsky as James Novak Eben Ham as Tanner Shaw Vanya Asher as Ethan Stoney Westmoreland as Hal Rimbeau Samantha Sloyan as Jeanine Locke Jennifer Peo as Vanessa Chandler Diahnna Nicole Baxter as News Anchor Erin Chambers as Mara Nicole Shalhoub as Flight Attendant Tara Platt as Navy Servicewoman Heather Ayers as Smug Cable Newswoman Co Starring Jay Jackson as Mike Waters