Guest Stars Scout Taylor-Compton as Emmy Thomas Austin Butler as Benjamin Gold Cassandra Jean Amell as Olivia Prescott Matt Angel as Allen Wilson Cherilyn Wilson as Becky Jeremy Glazer as Mr. Booker Paul Schackman as Wendell Andrews Co Starring Christina McDowell as Jennifer Spencer Timi Prulhiere as Nora Prescott Samantha Sergeant as Cheerleader #2 Robert Neary as Jack Prescott Audra Griffis as Cheerleader #1