Guest Stars Vanessa Lengies as Elf John Ducey as Thom Hinklejr Co Starring Darin Cooper as ICE Agent Vince Foster as USDA Agent Deja Dee as DEA Agent Adam Boyer as Morris Denitra Isler as Latisha Fletcher Jones as Young Nate Samuel G.P. Vielma as Marco Sebastian Greco as Caleb David Kronawitter as Dad Cop Matt McHugh as Newspaper Man Estes Tarver as Phil the Bartender Carla Stanley as Sales Rep Dolan Wilson as Santa Ming Zhuang as Asian Tourist