Guest Stars A.J. Langer as Erica Warner Stephen Amell as Scott Becker Blue Deckert as Detective Joe Price Brianna Brown as Sam's Date Edwin Hodge as Aaron Co Starring Griffin Gluck as Mason Warner Scott Alan Smith as Therapist Holly Gagnier as Nina Natalie Avital as Sissy David Ury as Hank Ajarae Coleman as Hot Waitress Jared Williams as Boy