Guest Stars Kevin McCorkle as Detective Gil Sherman Frederick Koehler as Neil Beaudry Virginia Williams as Brandi Beaudry Daveigh Chase as Ariel Shuman (1990) Judy Prescott as Kelly Baxter Carly Schroeder as Brandi Beaudry (1990) Abigail Mavity as Rita Baxter Nicholas Guest as Jason Beaudry Emma Bates as Ariel Shuman Katie Mitchell as Teacher in 1990 Ashley Rose Orr as Tiffany O'Connell (1990) Mary Chris Wall as Holly Beaudry Dawn Stahlak as Tiffany O'Connell Co Starring John Benjamin Martin as Detective McElroy Chaffee Graham as Gary Beaudry (1990)
