Guest Stars Patricia Bethune as Dr. Penny Davoren Shailene Woodley as Sarah Gunden Robyn Lively as Miriam Gunden Ashlee Gillespie as Rachel Wagler Sean Wing as Vince Patrielli MacKenzie Mauzy as Anna Gunden Christopher Shand as Jakob Beachy Co Starring Jesse C. Boyd as Rowdy Amish Teen #2 James Ingersoll as Phil Corado Sean Andrew as Rowdy Amish Teen #1 Chip Joslin as Mose Wagler
