Guest Stars Sonja Sohn as Toni Halstead Bellamy Young as Audrey Metz (1938) Jonathan Scarfe as Will Paige (1938) Lawrence Pressman as Robert "Dobber" Metz (2007) Peter Haskell as Will Paige (2007) Tuc Watkins as Felton Metz (1938) Ralph Waite as Felton Metz (2007) Sarah Laine as Penny Centavo (1938) Len Lesser as Elmer Gibbins (2007) Chip Hormess as Robert "Dobber" Metz (1938) Julianna McCarthy as Penny Centavo (2007) Co Starring Brian F. Durkin as Sailor (1938) James Sharpe as Buzz Moran (1938) Ari Zagaris as Elmer Gibbins (1938) Michael O'Dwyer as Bartender (1938)
