Guest Stars Carrie Preston as Elsbeth Tascioni Robert Klein as Lyle Pollard Dan Lauria as Ronnie Erickson Bhavesh Patel as Anthony Wright Edelman Tracee Chimo as Chrissy Helen Carey as Francesca Michael Mellamphy as Man in a Tux Bethany Hotchkiss as Lacey Erin Dilly as Joely Hallie Cooper-Novack as Jeannie Matt Wall as Silver Sneakers Instructor