Guest Stars Brad Leland as Buddy Garrity Glenn Morshower as Chad Clarke Benjamin Ciaramello as Santiago Herrera Jessalyn Gilsig as Shelley Hayes Kim Smith as Lauren Davis Alanna Ubach as Bobbie Roberts Co Starring Derek Phillips as Billy Riggins Blue Deckert as Mac McGill Timothy F. Crowley as Coach Crowley Liz Mikel as Corrina Williams Aaron Spivey-Sorrells as Coach Spivey Nieko Mann as Noannie Williams James Powers as Bradley Cole Whitney McCauley as Sheila Williams Katherine Willis as Joanne Street Mark Nutter as Mitchell Street Steven Walters as Glenn Reed James Kenneth Phillips as Reverend Phillips Pat Hazell as Detective Tambor Peter Malof as Principal Brecker Steve Shearer as Detective Ronnie Blair Billy Jaeger as Jimmy (Wrestling Student) Erick Smart as Shrader (Fullback)