Guest Stars Callie Thorne as Sheila Keefe Lenny Clarke as Uncle Teddy Charles Durning as Michael Gavin Robert John Burke as Father Mickey Gavin Michael Mulheren as Chief Perolli Ed Sullivan as Billy Warren Paula Devicq as Sondra Co Starring Natalie Distler as Colleen Gavin Michael Zegen as Damian Keefe Anthony Mangano as Bobby Muhammed Cunningham as Pajama Boy Jarah Mariano as Asian Girl Mackenzie Connolly as Kitten Girl Larisa Polonsky as Gina Aria Pullman as China Josh Pavloff as Vito Shavonne Conroy as Mary Brittany Slattery as Jo Brian McNamara as Passing Fireman Gordon Ramsey as Ricky Kelly Deadmon as Maddie Vincent Jessica Blank as Gloria Kevin Hagan as Chief #1 Jack McCormack as Chief #2 Michael Carlsen as Driver William Stone Mahoney as Priest Buddy McKay as Firefighter #1 Rick Fernandez as Firefighter #2