Guest Stars Callie Thorne as Sheila Keefe Lenny Clarke as Uncle Teddy Charles Durning as Michael Gavin Diane Farr as Laura Miles James Badge Dale as Timo Gavin Kaitlin Hopkins as Jennifer's Mom Co Starring Natalie Distler as Colleen Gavin Jimmy Burke as Andrew Todd Carroll as Collins Phoebe Strole as Jennifer Jenna Gavigan as Girl Dominic Marcus as Cop Jessica O'Donohue as Heather Rebecca O'Donahue as Brittany
