Guest Stars Lenny Clarke as Uncle Teddy Robert John Burke as Father Mickey Gavin Dean Winters as Johnny Gavin Michael Mulheren as Chief Perolli Lee Tergesen as Sully Robert Turano as S.I. Chief Co Starring Natalie Distler as Colleen Gavin Olivia Crocicchia as Katy Gavin Trevor Heins as Connor Gavin Peggy J. Scott as Jeannie Reilly Bernardo de Paula as Jesus Christ Ashlie Atkinson as Theresa David Vadim as Paulie Kristina Klebe as Mickey's Girlfriend Adam Mastrelli as Tony Tony Cucci as Sal James Biberi as Vinny Reginald Veneziano as Carmine John Speredakos as Jewish Cop Rob Munk as Walt Myk Watford as Steve Judy Del Giudice as Italian Woman Lou Patane as Contest Official
