Guest Stars Charles Durning as Michael Gavin Lenny Clarke as Uncle Teddy Robert John Burke as Father Mickey Gavin Milena Govich as Candy Christopher Durham as Father Murphy Co Starring Natalie Distler as Colleen Gavin Olivia Crocicchia as Katy Gavin Trevor Heins as Connor Gavin Bernardo de Paula as Jesus Christ Niels Jorgensen as Nils Todd Carroll as Collins Lyndon L. Byers as Ryan Ramón Rodríguez as Kevin Vasquez Cam Neely as Mungo Paul F. Martinowicz as Harry The Hat H. Jon Benjamin as Gary Christopher Youngsman as John The Stylist Stuart Evered as Cookie Guy #3 Paul Palandjian as Cookie Guy #2 Steve Hochmuth as Steve Walter J. Taylor as Referee Eric Bini as NYPD Hockey Player Brian Smiar as Doctor