Guest Stars Natalie Distler as Colleen Gavin Robert John Burke as Father Mickey Gavin Olivia Crocicchia as Katy Gavin Michael Zegen as Damian Keefe Jerry Adler as Sidney Feinberg Co Starring Niels Jorgensen as Nils Deanna Russo as Penny Rubano Will Chase as Pat Mahoney André De Shields as Paul Ezra Knight as Man Bernie McInerney as Dick Miller Clinton Lowe as Sleeping Man Joseph Sirola as Norman Ernestine Jackson as Elderly Black Woman