Guest Stars Lindsey Gort as Ashlee Matthew Kevin Anderson as Detective Rudy Lovello Saidah Arrika Ekulona as Sheriff Graham Colin Lawrence as Damien Westbrook Rey Gallegos as Ray Florez Mekia Cox as Jasmine Evans Tyler Poelle as Jeremy Hawkins Co Starring Ian Butcher as Mr. Green Rustin Gresiuk as High School Jeremy Grayson Maxwell Gurnsey as High School Russell Dion Riley as Denny Breanne Kelly as High School Dora