Guest Stars Nicholas Lea as Tom Foss Chelan Simmons as Hillary Shepard Cory Monteith as Charlie Tanner Sarah Jane Redmond as Rebecca Thatcher Andrew Jackson as Cyrus Reynolds Co Starring Kurt Max Runte as Detective Jason Breen Carrie Genzel as Julia Peterson Aaron Craven as Dr. Lawrence Iris Paluly as Woman Marsha Regis as Kim Sanford Shaker Paleja as Manny Jones