Special Guest Stars Joshua Malina as Peter Alpert Guest Stars Aaron Ashmore as Scott Griffin Erika Alexander as Theresa Simmons Keith Nobbs as Charlie Connor James Read as Damon Schmidt Susan Chuang as Abby Montgomery Esteban Powell as Walter Cooper Matt Winston as Tim Bickman Co Starring Joey Zimmerman as Stranger #2 Jonathan Ragsdale as Trevor Cushing Galen Hutchison as Vance Stephen A. Eiland as Marty Ray Guzman Charles Gamble as Stranger #1 Scott Cervine as Businessman