Guest Stars Corinne Massiah as Lucy Malloy Brian Gattas as Randy Ary Katz as Jonah Camila Banus as Kylie Jerry O'Connell as Robert Niles Fitch as Noel Tia Mowry as Barbara Rutledge Robert Fukuzaki as Reporter Jarod Joseph as Wilson Nick Toth as Judge Lisa Canning as Prosecutor Matthew Borlenghi as Defense Attorney James Tucker as Court Clerk