Special Guest Stars Jason Wiles as Colin Robbins Guest Stars Katherine Cannon as Felice Martin Emma Caulfield as Susan Keats Brooke Theiss as Leslie Sumner Rebecca Gayheart as Antonia "Toni" Marchette Caroline Lagerfelt as Sheila Silver Ken Lerner as Jerry Korman Doren Fein as Jessica Korman Co Starring Wesley Allen Gullick as Willie Cliff Weissman as Bruno Sarah Lilly as Female Police Officer Albert Garcia as Paramedic Jill Ritchie as Nose Ring Girl Eugenia Yuan as Girl #1 Sandra Francis as Judge #1