Guest Stars Eric Szmanda as Gregory "Greg" Sanders Skip O'Brien as Det. Ray O'Riley Madison McReynolds as Lindsey Willows Aasif Mandvi as Dr. Leever Greg Collins as Officer Arvington Krista Allen as Kristy Hopkins Matt O'Toole as Paul Milander Harrison Young as Judge Cohen Susan Gibney as Charlotte Meridian Chandra West as Holly Gribbs Barbara Tarbuck as Paige Harmon Jeff Snyder as Officer Smith John Pyper-Ferguson as Mr. Mandalay Royce D. Applegate as Mr. Laferty Ashly Holloway as Laura Scott John Henry Whitaker as Jimmy Allan Rich as Dr. Gary Klausbach Cedrick Terrell as Bo Wilson Terra Gold as Gina Harmon Co Starring Nancy Fish as Store Owner Garland Whitt as Black Male Joseph Patrick Kelly as Hotel Security Jane Leigh Connelly as Wife Uncredited Madeleine Falk as Catherine's Sister
