Special Guest Stars Jaclyn Smith as Olivia Hodges Guest Stars Marc Vann as Conrad Ecklie Sheeri Rappaport as Mandy Webster Jeffrey D. Stevens as Paramedic Pedro Pascal as Kyle Hartley / Cheshire Cat / Paramedic #2 Cameron Richardson as Emily Hartley / White Rabbit / Salesgirl Christopher Knight as Pastor Nadia Bjorlin as Crystal Hasselbeck Evan Parke as Eli / Security Guard Peter Jason as Walter Gersh Amanda Jane Cooper as Lisa Cravitz / Alice / Bride Sara Van Horn as Nana of the Bride Sam Harris as Alan Wilson / Caterpillar