Guest Stars Alona Tal as Natalie Edreau Melinda Page Hamilton as Katie Sasha Roiz as Keith Wolcott David Burke as Kevin Haightly Elon Gold as Paul Fricke Co Starring Gina Marie May as Sara-Beth Lori Lively as Molly Maya Goodwin as Kara Lucia Sullivan as Woman Anthony Tyler Quinn as Lawyer Alex Quijano as Attendant Camden Singer as Doctor Jacqueline Hickel as Darby Uncredited Kelly Frazier as Cho's Waitress