Guest Stars Mouzam Makkar as Jessica Kirsten Fitzgerald as Maria Walters Robert Emmet Lunney as Dapper Man / The Salesman Brad Armacost as Bishop Donald Egan Co Starring Alan Metoskie as Red Charlotte Thomas as Julia April Sutton as Mom Oksana Fedunyszyn as The Crone Sandra Delgado as Isabel Adam Bitterman as Father Sean Griffin Kane as Young Marcus D'Wayne Taylor as Therapist Javoun Baker as College Student Autumn Dolores Pippenburg as Amazon Bries Vannon as Emaciated Man Krystal Ortiz as Casey's Teammate Charlie Babbo as Orphan Boy Uncredited Francis Guinan as Brother Simon
