Guest Stars Bill Mondy as Deputy Roscoe Chris Shields as Deputy Nicole Muñoz as Little Eva Lourdes Benedicto as Eva Cortez Wilmer Calderon as Miguel John Innes as Father O'Connor Victor Ayala as Mikey @ 15 yrs Alonso Oyarzun as Enrique Santo Lombardo as Driver / Jose Sina Najafi as Mikey @ 11 yrs Michael-Ann Connor as Carla Cummings Helenna Santos as Carmen / Mother