Guest Stars Jason George as Keith Bennett Jodi Long as Judge Marcia Phelps Steve Harris as Jayson Turk Patrick Breen as A.D.A. Paul Sweren Meta Golding as Carly Turk Rob Nagle as Jeffrey Powell Matt DeCaro as Judge Salese James Remar as Arvin Solinsky Andy Mackenzie as Tattooed Guy Co Starring Robert A. Johnson as Jury Foreperson Mel Fair as Anchor Greta Sesheta as Association Member #1