Guest Stars Tom Cavanagh as Jeremy Stone Pamela Reed as Mrs. Stone Kirsten Nelson as Amy Asbury Michael B. Silver as Elliott Russell Andrea Bogart as Carrie David Marshall Grant as Martin Ostrow Reggie Austin as Dr. Frances David Barry Gray as Danny Asbury Blake Robbins as Howard Masters Co Starring Katherine Ann McGregor as Judge Wilma Harding Susie Geiser as Dina Allston Nathaniel Harris as Jury Foreman Marcus Smith III as Bailiff