Guest Stars Jerry O'Connell as Detective Woodrow "Woody" Hoyt David Monahan as Detective Matt Seely Jennifer Finnigan as Dr. Devan Maguire Jim Beaver as Ranger Diggory John D'Aquino as Harold Fallon Silas Weir Mitchell as Alastair Dark Victor Raider-Wexler as Maury Morgan Rusler as Amos Tibbs Co Starring Jerry Trainor as Brian from A.V. Phil Abrams as Samuel Burnham Matt Eyde as Mike Annabelle Milne as Elvira