Guest Stars Allan McLeod as Paul Jillian Todd Robert Anderson as Vernon Barbara Janet Varney as Becca Barbara Shane Francis Smith as Killian Mounce Collette Wolfe as Dorothy Durwood Steve Agee as Dutch Doug Benson as Himself Samira Wiley as Justina Jordan Co Starring Colin Campbell as Barfly Heather Brooker as School Teacher Joseph Buttler as Paul's Lawyer Andrea Helene as Friend #2 Alden Ray as Friend #1 Pam Cook as Friend #3