Guest Stars David Haydn-Jones as Arthur Ketch Paloma Kwiatkowski as Magda Peterson Aliza Vellani as Beth Roberts William MacDonald as Abraham Peterson Christina Carlisi as Gail Peterson Co Starring Mariessa Portelance as Olivia Sanchez Rick Tae as Father Valdecantos Natalie Von Rotsburg as Driver Cheryl Mullen as Woman With Rosary Gig Morton as Elijah Peterson Jeremy Arnold as Coroner Carl Daniel Jeffery as Ricky Copeland Elissa Ciullo as Mother Thomas Haddaway-Graham as Young Boy