Guest Stars William Sadler as William Frost Wade Williams as Alvin Hawkins Rylee Fansler as Young Annie Frost Co Starring Mathew Greer as Tipster Amelia Jeffries as Officer Monroe Steve Mokate as Clark Perry Leticia Magaña as Cashier Steven Walters as Brian "Bouf" Bouffton Russell DeGrazier as Seller Chris Olson as Stan Larsen Todd Upchurch as Ross Cullem