Special Guest Stars Josh Meyers as Barry Gage Golightly as Karen Guest Stars Alexandra Turshen as Misty Freddie Roman as Herb Gina Gershon as Fay Getty Annabelle Dexter-Jones as Xan Mark Linn-Baker as Rabbi Ken Kaplan Brad Gilbert as Stan Feinberg Beth Stelling as Margot Co Starring Greer Barnes as Terry Ann Carr as Gail Deborah Fennelly as Yvonne Juliet Brett as Tabitha Shane Nepveu as Eli Will Roland as Joel Miriam A. Hyman as Janice Kate MacCluggage as Gladys Adam Langdon as Josh Caitlin McDonough-Thayer as Karaoke Woman Mollie Israel as Bar Patron Alex Rennie as Bartender