Guest Stars Cody Christian as Theo Raeken Victoria Moroles as Hayden Romero Tamlyn Tomita as Noshiko Yukimura Marti Matulis as The Outlaw Joey Honsa as Claudia Stilinski Pete Ploszek as Garrett Douglas Alexander Ward as The Enforcer Kevin Ogilvie as The Ranger McNally Sagal as Lenore Mason McNulty as Caleb Co Starring Meghan McGarry as Younger Lenore