Guest Stars Mouzam Makkar as Jessica Kirsten Fitzgerald as Maria Walters Robert Emmet Lunney as Dapper Man / The Salesman Francis Guinan as Brother Simon Tim Hopper as Superintendent Jaffey Deanna Dunagan as Mother Bernadette Ken Marks as Lester Rego Keira Naughton as Cherry Rego Brad Armacost as Bishop Donald Egan James Vincent Meredith as Detective Lawrence Co Starring Torrey Hanson as Cardinal Guillot Melissa Russell as Tara Wendy Mateo as Parishioner #1 Mattie Hawkinson as Gala Guest #1