Guest Stars Marc Evan Jackson as Shawn Tiya Sircar as The Real Eleanor / Vicky / Denise Eugene Cordero as Steven "Pillboi" Peleaz Amy Okuda as Gayle / Jessica Susan Park as Pevita Rebecca Delgado Smith as Pilar Co Starring Josh Siegal as Glenn Ruman Kazi as Sachveer Will McLaughlin as Officer Prawnmandler Jen Statsky as Susan