Main Characters Eli McCullough 20 main appearances Pete McCullough 20 main appearances Maria Garcia 20 main appearances Jeannie McCullough 20 main appearances Sally 20 main appearances Young Eli McCullough 20 main appearances Phineas McCullough 20 main appearances Niles 18 main appearances Prairie Flower 18 main appearances Toshaway 17 main appearances Charles McCullough 8 main appearances Young Ingrid 9 main appearances Garcia 10 main appearances
Recurring Guest Characters Charles McCullough 7 guest appearances Young Ingrid 4 guest appearances Jonas McCullough 8 guest appearances Neptune 6 guest appearances Charges the Enemy 6 guest appearances Eugene Monahan 6 guest appearances Tom Sullivan 5 guest appearances Matthew Wentworth 5 guest appearances Ulises Gonzales 5 guest appearances Nocona 5 guest appearances Jeanne Anne McCullough 5 guest appearances Sheriff Moses Dart 5 guest appearances Virgil 4 guest appearances Fat Wolf 4 guest appearances Aniceto Pizaña 3 guest appearances Gus Hallie 3 guest appearances Vincent Hastings 3 guest appearances Scalped-A-Dog 3 guest appearances Cesar Sanchez 2 guest appearances Martin 2 guest appearances ⇤ « 1 2 3 4 5 » ⇥