Recurring Guest Characters Caroline Rhea 21 guest appearances Jack McBrayer 12 guest appearances Cheryl Hines 11 guest appearances Jane Krakowski 11 guest appearances Ellie Kemper 10 guest appearances Mario Cantone 10 guest appearances Niecy Nash 9 guest appearances Constance Zimmer 9 guest appearances Ana Gasteyer 8 guest appearances Sherri Shepherd 8 guest appearances Joel McHale 8 guest appearances Tituss Burgess 7 guest appearances Horatio Sanz 7 guest appearances Jason Alexander 6 guest appearances Adam Carolla 6 guest appearances Kenan Thompson 5 guest appearances Mark Duplass 5 guest appearances Thomas Lennon 5 guest appearances Rosie O'Donnell 4 guest appearances Ali Wentworth 4 guest appearances ⇤ « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 » ⇥