Main Characters Mary Sibley 36 main appearances John Alden 36 main appearances Cotton Mather 36 main appearances Anne Hale 36 main appearances Mercy Lewis 36 main appearances Isaac Walton 36 main appearances Tituba 35 main appearances Baron Sebastian Marburg 23 main appearances John 20 main appearances Magistrate Hale 12 main appearances
Recurring Guest Characters Female Refugee 1 guest appearances Dead Petrus 1 guest appearances Mrs. Stoughton 1 guest appearances Mr. Stoughton 1 guest appearances Rebecca Nurse 1 guest appearances Lark 1 guest appearances Puritan 1 guest appearances Refugee 1 guest appearances Dock Worker 1 guest appearances Mercy Bird 1 guest appearances John Sibley / The Devil 1 guest appearances ⇤ « 1 2 3 4 5 6 » ⇥