Recurring Guest Characters Paul Wesley 1 guest appearances Bonnie Wright 1 guest appearances Oliver Phelps 1 guest appearances James Phelps 1 guest appearances Jamie Kennedy 1 guest appearances Anthony LaPaglia 1 guest appearances Ryan Kelley 1 guest appearances Vincent D'Onofrio 1 guest appearances Heather Langenkamp 1 guest appearances Candice Accola 1 guest appearances Richard Blade 1 guest appearances Peter Facinelli 1 guest appearances David Krumholtz 1 guest appearances Adrianne Palicki 1 guest appearances Keanu Reeves 1 guest appearances Robert Mailhouse 1 guest appearances Bret Domrose 1 guest appearances Tom Ellis 1 guest appearances Rachel Bilson 1 guest appearances Shelley Hennig 1 guest appearances ⇤ « 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 » ⇥