Recurring Guest Characters James Marsters 2 guest appearances Nathan Fillion 2 guest appearances Erica Durance 2 guest appearances Katee Sackhoff 2 guest appearances Joel McHale 2 guest appearances Alan Ritchson 2 guest appearances Michael Biehn 2 guest appearances Emily Kinney 1 guest appearances Tara Lipinski 1 guest appearances Kristen Bell 1 guest appearances Justin Hartley 1 guest appearances Chris Hardwick 1 guest appearances Colin Hanks 1 guest appearances Jeanie Buss 1 guest appearances Rob McElhenney 1 guest appearances Karen Gillan 1 guest appearances Topher Grace 1 guest appearances Michael Gervais 1 guest appearances Jana Kramer 1 guest appearances Andrew McMahon 1 guest appearances ⇤ « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 » ⇥