Main Characters Pam Hupp 6 main appearances Leah Askey 6 main appearances Mariah Day 6 main appearances Mark Hupp 6 main appearances Russ Faria 6 main appearances Betsy Faria 5 main appearances Joel Schwartz 5 main appearances Janet 5 main appearances Detective Ryan McCarrick 4 main appearances
Recurring Guest Characters Randy Gunderson 1 guest appearances Bubbly Acolyte 1 guest appearances Auctioneer 1 1 guest appearances Cybercrimes Expert 1 guest appearances Teen Witch 1 guest appearances Sarah at 6 Years Old 1 guest appearances Sarah at 11 Years Old 1 guest appearances Young Pam 1 guest appearances Bob Rivers 1 guest appearances Judge Ted House 1 guest appearances Michael J. Kruse 1 guest appearances Teen Pet Shop Employee 1 guest appearances Realtor Sally 1 guest appearances Zumba Instructor 1 guest appearances Big Shot Manager 1 guest appearances Detective Brian Hilke 1 guest appearances Carol Alford 1 guest appearances Officer Carrigan 1 guest appearances Bradford Kessler 1 guest appearances Judge Cunningham 1 guest appearances ⇤ « 1 2 3 4 » ⇥