Recurring Guest Characters Keith Urban 2 guest appearances John Lithgow 2 guest appearances Jeff Probst 2 guest appearances Peter Krause 2 guest appearances Nicole Byer 2 guest appearances Gillian Jacobs 1 guest appearances Danica McKellar 1 guest appearances Veronica "Pooh" Nash-Poleate 1 guest appearances Tony Danza 1 guest appearances Jurnee Smollett-Bell 1 guest appearances RJ Cyler 1 guest appearances Dalen Spratt 1 guest appearances Juwan Mass 1 guest appearances Marcus Harvey 1 guest appearances Margaret Anne Florence 1 guest appearances Zosia Mamet 1 guest appearances Afton Williamson 1 guest appearances Freddie Stroma 1 guest appearances Alfonso Ribeiro 1 guest appearances Martha Plimpton 1 guest appearances ⇤ « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 » ⇥