Try 30 days of free premium.

How I Caught My Killer - Episode Guide

Season 1

"Social media? Yeah, it was her thing."

Episode: 1x01 | Airdate: Jan 12, 2023 (46 min)

"Social media? Yeah, it was her thing."

Nikki Kuhnhausen lives loud and proud on social media. Born male, Nikki has openly identified as female since middle school. When the 17-year-old goes missing, her own social media helps police unravel the mystery. 

"I found Candice's Diary…"

Episode: 1x02 | Airdate: Jan 12, 2023 (42 min)

"I found Candice's Diary…"

When 14-year-old Candice Parchment goes missing, the police write her off as a runaway. Months later, her body is found blocks from her home. Investigators are stumped until Candice's own writing helps uncover the horrifying truth .

"It's just unfathomable…"

Episode: 1x03 | Airdate: Jan 12, 2023 (46 min)

"It's just unfathomable…"

In 2012, Brandy Rosine drives an hour into Pennsylvania, but as night falls, the college student stops answering her family's calls. It's up to her mom to follow a trail of digital breadcrumbs Brandy left behind to find her.

"Everybody was always looking at him."

Episode: 1x04 | Airdate: Jan 12, 2023 (43 min)

"Everybody was always looking at him."

Shockwaves rip through a college campus in Missouri when 21-year-old Jesse Valencia is found, his throat slashed. With a litany of suspects – and a secret revealed by Jesse – investigators must untangle a web.

"She's only fourteen and she's not home."

Episode: 1x05 | Airdate: Jan 12, 2023 (49 min)

"She's only fourteen and she's not home."

In the winter of 2013, 14-year-old Shaniesha Forbes never made it home after school. Her charred remains turn up on a Brooklyn beach days later, but this teen leaves behind a mountain of digital evidence for the NYPD to sift.

"You can see the panic."

Episode: 1x06 | Airdate: Jan 12, 2023 (49 min)

"You can see the panic."

Armada, Michigan could be ripped from a Norman Rockwell painting, but the town changes forever when April Millsap's body is found. Police search for the teen's missing phone and discover a fitness app.

"He was speaking to us from the grave."

Episode: 1x07 | Airdate: Jan 12, 2023 (43 min)

"He was speaking to us from the grave."

When 32-year-old John Ray is murdered in his Atlanta home, investigators are stumped. For seven years, his case goes unsolved until cold case detectives take another look at the evidence.

"There might be a target on your back."

Episode: 1x08 | Airdate: Jan 12, 2023 (49 min)

"There might be a target on your back."

In rural Missouri, reptile breeder Ben Renick is found dead–surrounded by his collection of exotic snakes. Investigators have to wade through dozens of potential suspects before finding a text chain from Ben.

"There was a monster inside of him."

Episode: 1x09 | Airdate: Jan 12, 2023 (51 min)

"There was a monster inside of him."

In 2016, in the shadow of Manhattan's skyline, a killer stalks women undetected. But a quick-thinking friend, a final phone call, and a social media chat log point to a serial killer who may never have been caught.

Season 2

It Was a Religious Hate Crime

Episode: 2x01 | Airdate: Jul 18, 2024 (43 min)

It Was a Religious Hate Crime

Devout Mennonite Sasha Krause vanishes from her church parking lot in the middle of the night, investigators follow a series of unlikely digital clues across state lines to a gruesome discovery and uncover a killer with burning hatred.

I Know What the Devil Looks Like

Episode: 2x02 | Airdate: Jul 18, 2024 (42 min)

I Know What the Devil Looks Like

When beloved teacher and mother-to-be Laura Wallen disappears before the first day of school, a seemingly innocent photo could be the key to unravelling an intricate web of deception and secret lovers that shatters a tightknit Maryland community.

 

She Was Hiding a Secret

Episode: 2x03 | Airdate: Jul 18, 2024 (42 min)

She Was Hiding a Secret

Twin sisters Jholie and Zhane Moussa share everything with each other, including their darkest secrets. So, when Jholie vanishes after meeting a mysterious boy, Zhane might be the only one who can help detectives learn the truth about her sister's fate.

There's No Peace in My Family

Episode: 2x04 | Airdate: Jul 18, 2024 (42 min)

There's No Peace in My Family

After a series of troubling posts appear on her social media, single-mother Julie Gonzalez vanishes. Desperate to learn the truth, her family works with the police and media, but it's Julie's own words that could reveal her fate and catch her killer.

She Was a Tough Girl

Episode: 2x05 | Airdate: Jul 18, 2024 (41 min)

She Was a Tough Girl

Mindy Morganstern refuses to let anything, even a devastating Muscular Sclerosis diagnosis, defeat her. So when she's brutally killed, it's her refusal to go down without a fight that could be the key to solving her murder.

There's More Than One Scumbag Out There

Episode: 2x06 | Airdate: Jul 18, 2024 (42 min)

There's More Than One Scumbag Out There

After the body of Brittany Clardy is discovered – frozen solid, in the backseat of her car – it's the discovery of a mysterious burner cell phone that reveals a secret life, and a list of suspects that may include a budding serial killer.

Obsessions Oftentimes Lead to Murder

Episode: 2x07 | Airdate: Jul 18, 2024 (44 min)

Obsessions Oftentimes Lead to Murder

Morgan Fox is a model employee with a bright future, but when she's found shot dead in a car just outside her own front door, investigators hope Morgan's own words can determine if she's the victim of a toxic coworker, or someone closer to her.

 

Every Shot He Took, I Felt It

Episode: 2x08 | Airdate: Jul 18, 2024 (42 min)

Every Shot He Took, I Felt It

When police find Atlanta rapper Rahim Grant gunned down in his apartment along with the critically injured mother of his child, the only way to learn who pulled the trigger – and why – could be locked in a series of shocking videos on Rahim's cellphone.

They'd Never Find the Body

Episode: 2x09 | Airdate: Jul 18, 2024 (43 min)

They'd Never Find the Body

19-year-old Jodi Sanderholm is responsible and dependable, so when she disappears a few days before her first niece is to be born, detectives must follow a gruesome trail of Jodi's breadcrumbs they hope will uncover a secret monster.

I Know That There is True Evil Out There

Episode: 2x10 | Airdate: Jul 18, 2024 (42 min)

I Know That There is True Evil Out There

When Kevin Bacon never returns home from a Christmas Eve hookup, his friends fear the disappearance is related to recent terrifying abductions, while detectives decipher a series of screenshots they hope will reveal Kevin's fate. 

Try 30 days of free premium.