Special Guest Stars Adina Porter as Lettie Mae Thornton Guest Stars Allan Hyde as Godric Gregg Daniel as Reverend Daniels J. Smith-Cameron as Melinda Mickens Courtney Ford as Portia Cooper Huckabee as Joe Lee Mickens Daniel Buran as Marcus Bozeman Annie Fitzgerald as Kirsch Vedette Lim as Naomi Paola Turbay as Antonia Alexandra Breckenridge as Katerina Del Zamora as Don Bartolo Peter MacDissi as Luis Ismael Carlo as Don Santiago Co Starring Damion Poitier as Duprez Aaron Perilo as Blackburn Valenzia Algarin as Maria Poncho Hodges as Officer Trap Diahnna Nicole Baxter as Witch #1 Dahlia Waingort as Witch #2 Silvia Curiel as Witch #3 Misha Gonz-Cirkl as Witch #4 Gabriel Solis as Young Jesus