Guest Stars Geoffrey Cantor as Mitchell Ellison Peter McRobbie as Father Paul Lantom Kate Udall as SAC Tammy Hattley Don Castro as Agent Arinori Matthew McCurdy as Agent Wellers Peter Halpin as Theo Nelson Skylar Gaertner as Young Matt Murdock Michael Mulheren as Edward Nelson John Francis McNamara as Uncle Timmy Nelson Deirdre O'Connell as Anna Nelson Andy Lucien as Agent Ramsey Dina Shihabi as Neda Kazemi Bill Winkler as Warden Riggle Jarrett Worley as Kidnapper Matt DeAngelis as Jasper Evans Anne Carney as Aunt Jeanie Nelson Arden Wolfe as Nelson Niece Jonathan O'Reilly as Nelson Nephew Chris Colombo as Mr. Kazemi Antoni Corone as Police Commissioner Chris DiMolina Ari Blinder as Agent #3 Gavin Haag as EMT James Foster, Jr. as Old Man Ron Fehmiu as Albanian Mob Boss Martin Chavez as Man Patrick Cann as Agent #2 DeShawn Harold Mitchell as Agent #1 Anabel Graetz as Old Albanian Woman Elisabeth Ness as Young Mother Oliver Palmer as Delivery Guy