Guest Stars William Windom as Dr. Seth Hazlitt Ron Masak as Sheriff Mort Metzger Louis Herthum as Deputy Andy Broom Madlyn Rhue as Jean O'Neill Željko Ivanek as Eddie Saunders Megan Follows as Lila Nolan Audra Lindley as Maggie Saunders Stephanie Niznik as Dorie Saunders Tom O'Brien as Jason Giles Frances Bay as Sarah McCoy William Converse-Roberts as Justin Haynes Elizabeth Wilson as Serena Haynes Mark Arnott as Dr. Kyle Adderly Ed Nelson as Henry Post Robert Rothwell as Lucas McCoy Kathryn Masak as Reporter #1